Difference between revisions of "Publish America, LLP"
(Controversial Page: I gave it my best shot) |
m (→Criticism: - typo) |
||
| (4 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | Publish America is a Maryland-based book publisher founded in 1999 by Lawrence Alvin "Larry" Clopper III and Willem Meiners. It has been the subject of controversy because it has been accused of being a vanity press or author mill by some writers and authors' advocates despite its claims to be a "traditional" advance- and royalty-paying publisher. [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Publish_America] | + | [[Category:Publishers]][[Category:Print Publishers]][[Category:Controversial Pages]] |
| + | Publish America is a Maryland-based book publisher founded in 1999 by Lawrence Alvin "Larry" Clopper III and Willem Meiners. It has been the subject of controversy because it has been accused of being a [[Vanity Press|vanity press]] or author mill by some writers and authors' advocates despite its claims to be a "traditional" advance- and royalty-paying publisher. [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Publish_America] | ||
==Services Offered== | ==Services Offered== | ||
| − | Publish America pays a "small" (US$1 [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Publish_America]) advance to its authors, and claims | + | Publish America pays a "small" (US$1 [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Publish_America]) advance to its authors, and claims to pay all the expenses involved with acquiring, producing, manufacturing, and publishing a book. [http://www.publishamerica.com/facts/index.htm] |
==Official Site== | ==Official Site== | ||
| Line 9: | Line 10: | ||
==Criticism== | ==Criticism== | ||
| − | Critics | + | Critics argue that '''Publish America''' presents itself as a traditional house, but acts like a vanity publisher. Writers who contacted [http://www.publishersweekly.com Publisher's Weekly] in 2004 had complained that Publish America sells books to which it no longer holds the rights, offers authors only a 30% discount, doesn't pay royalties it owes, engages in slipshod editing and copyediting, sets unreasonable list prices (national average for a trade paperback is $16, PublishAmerica's is closer to $20 [http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A24113-2005Jan20.html]), and makes little effort in getting books into bookstores. [http://www.publishersweekly.com/article/CA481863.html] On average, data indicates Publish America sells less than 100 copies of each title. [http://www.critters.org/sting/] |
While Publish America doesn't charge for printing the books, it does require authors to provide a list of friends and family, and then markets to them heavily, according to the authors. [http://www.publishersweekly.com/article/CA481863.html] | While Publish America doesn't charge for printing the books, it does require authors to provide a list of friends and family, and then markets to them heavily, according to the authors. [http://www.publishersweekly.com/article/CA481863.html] | ||
===Sting=== | ===Sting=== | ||
| − | In 2004, after a representative of Publish America made derogatory remarks about the genre of Science fiction, a host of well-known sci-fi writers, headed by James D Macdonald[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlanta_Nights] | + | In 2004, after a representative of Publish America made derogatory remarks about the genre of Science fiction, a host of well-known sci-fi writers, headed by James D Macdonald conspired to prove the publisher a vanity press.[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlanta_Nights] At the time, the house claimed to reject 80% of all manuscripts submitted. |
| − | The result was a 41-chapter novel where each chapter was written by a separate author except for 17 (repeat of Chapter 4), Chapter 21 (missing), and Chapter 34 (written by the [http://www.critters.org/bonsai.html Bonzai Story Generator]). Authors worked from a loose outline that included an "it was all a dream" ending, and were encouraged to include "obvious grammatical errors and nonsensical passages". [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlanta_Nights] | + | The result was a 41-chapter novel where each chapter was written by a separate author, except for 17 (repeat of Chapter 4), Chapter 21 (missing), and Chapter 34 (written by the [http://www.critters.org/bonsai.html Bonzai Story Generator]). Authors worked from a loose outline that included an "it was all a dream" ending, and were encouraged to include "obvious grammatical errors and nonsensical passages". [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlanta_Nights] |
| − | The manuscript was accepted for publication on 7 December 2004 without comment, despite the claim made by | + | The manuscript was accepted for publication on 7 December 2004 without comment, despite the claim made by Publish America that "We read every single submission before we accept or refuse." |
The Manuscript can be read here: [http://www.cs.du.edu/~aburt/StingManuscript.pdf Altanta Nights] (''Warning: PDF'') | The Manuscript can be read here: [http://www.cs.du.edu/~aburt/StingManuscript.pdf Altanta Nights] (''Warning: PDF'') | ||
| − | And the history (including the acceptance letter) is available at: [http://www.critters.org/sting/ The Critter's PublishAmerica page] | + | And the history (including the acceptance letter) is available at: [http://www.critters.org/sting/ The Critter's PublishAmerica page]. |
Latest revision as of 15:02, 8 November 2007
Publish America is a Maryland-based book publisher founded in 1999 by Lawrence Alvin "Larry" Clopper III and Willem Meiners. It has been the subject of controversy because it has been accused of being a vanity press or author mill by some writers and authors' advocates despite its claims to be a "traditional" advance- and royalty-paying publisher. [1]
Services Offered
Publish America pays a "small" (US$1 [2]) advance to its authors, and claims to pay all the expenses involved with acquiring, producing, manufacturing, and publishing a book. [3]
Official Site
Criticism
Critics argue that Publish America presents itself as a traditional house, but acts like a vanity publisher. Writers who contacted Publisher's Weekly in 2004 had complained that Publish America sells books to which it no longer holds the rights, offers authors only a 30% discount, doesn't pay royalties it owes, engages in slipshod editing and copyediting, sets unreasonable list prices (national average for a trade paperback is $16, PublishAmerica's is closer to $20 [4]), and makes little effort in getting books into bookstores. [5] On average, data indicates Publish America sells less than 100 copies of each title. [6]
While Publish America doesn't charge for printing the books, it does require authors to provide a list of friends and family, and then markets to them heavily, according to the authors. [7]
Sting
In 2004, after a representative of Publish America made derogatory remarks about the genre of Science fiction, a host of well-known sci-fi writers, headed by James D Macdonald conspired to prove the publisher a vanity press.[8] At the time, the house claimed to reject 80% of all manuscripts submitted.
The result was a 41-chapter novel where each chapter was written by a separate author, except for 17 (repeat of Chapter 4), Chapter 21 (missing), and Chapter 34 (written by the Bonzai Story Generator). Authors worked from a loose outline that included an "it was all a dream" ending, and were encouraged to include "obvious grammatical errors and nonsensical passages". [9]
The manuscript was accepted for publication on 7 December 2004 without comment, despite the claim made by Publish America that "We read every single submission before we accept or refuse."
The Manuscript can be read here: Altanta Nights (Warning: PDF)
And the history (including the acceptance letter) is available at: The Critter's PublishAmerica page.
