Difference between revisions of "Help talk:Style Manual"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(→It's A Start: Author name format) |
(Organizing, reissued books question for style) |
||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
This page looks great and has been SOOO helpful, there are no words. Thanks, [[User:Kay T|Kay T]]! ---[[User:Robini|Robini]] 14:35, 11 September 2007 (PDT) | This page looks great and has been SOOO helpful, there are no words. Thanks, [[User:Kay T|Kay T]]! ---[[User:Robini|Robini]] 14:35, 11 September 2007 (PDT) | ||
| + | == Author Name Format == | ||
:Oh, but one question - (Ok, two now that I think about it) | :Oh, but one question - (Ok, two now that I think about it) | ||
::1) Did you want to include instructions for Author names with spaces (like we ran into in the [[Cheryl St.John]] v. [[Cheryl St. John]] issue, and | ::1) Did you want to include instructions for Author names with spaces (like we ran into in the [[Cheryl St.John]] v. [[Cheryl St. John]] issue, and | ||
| − | ::2) When listing authors alphabetically, should we bother with "Firstname Last|Lastname First" syntax as they do here - [[Erotic Romance]], or just leave the format as "Firstname Last" Format, to avoid confusion when new users populate pages? Personally, I am leaning towards the latter, having just found articles for "Racy Li" and "Li, Racy" that were identical, and most likely came from the page I linked to. | + | ::2) When listing authors alphabetically, should we bother with "Firstname Last|Lastname First" syntax as they do here - [[Erotic Romance]], or just leave the format as "Firstname Last" Format, to avoid confusion when new users populate pages? Personally, I am leaning towards the latter, having just found articles for "Racy Li" and "Li, Racy" that were identical, and most likely came from the page I linked to.--[[User:Robini|Robini]] 14:43, 11 September 2007 (PDT) |
| − | |||
| − | Things to add: | + | :::Things to add: |
| − | ''1 - Author names with spaces (like we ran into in the [[Cheryl St.John]] v. [[Cheryl St. John]] issue'' - what did we decide on this? | + | :::''1 - Author names with spaces (like we ran into in the [[Cheryl St.John]] v. [[Cheryl St. John]] issue'' - what did we decide on this? |
| − | ''2 - Author names when more than one author with same name -'' What did we decide on this? | + | :::''2 - Author names when more than one author with same name -'' What did we decide on this? |
| − | ''3 - how to list Author names in list:'' | + | :::''3 - how to list Author names in list:'' |
:::okay, I sort of like the list entries to be Last, First (but I had recently noticed the problem with author pages being created in that format too!). The author "First Last" format is what shows up in categories, I think. Maybe we should leave this out there for discussion a little while. --[[User:Kay T|Kay T]] 16:02, 11 September 2007 (PDT) | :::okay, I sort of like the list entries to be Last, First (but I had recently noticed the problem with author pages being created in that format too!). The author "First Last" format is what shows up in categories, I think. Maybe we should leave this out there for discussion a little while. --[[User:Kay T|Kay T]] 16:02, 11 September 2007 (PDT) | ||
::::My thought: Have all be of the same format "First Last". If you wish to display them as "Last, First" do so using the pipe: <nowiki>[[First Last | Last, First]]</nowiki>. And do redirects for any pages that already created under the Last, First to First Last. | ::::My thought: Have all be of the same format "First Last". If you wish to display them as "Last, First" do so using the pipe: <nowiki>[[First Last | Last, First]]</nowiki>. And do redirects for any pages that already created under the Last, First to First Last. | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Reissued books == | ||
| + | More Style guide questions. What is the stance on books that have been reissued? There are a bunch by [[Kate Hill]] | ||
| + | *[[Darkness Therein (reissue)]] | ||
| + | *[[Immaculate (reissue)]] | ||
| + | *[[Infernal (reissue)]] | ||
| + | *[[God of the Grim (reissue)]] | ||
| + | And they have (reissue) in the title. I can tell from websearching that these were all previously published, but that those publications are no longer in print. Personally, I think having one page for the title (sans reissue) with a note that they were originally published elsewhere (include name of publication/publisher if possible) and that they are currently published by Ellora's Cave. Which would mean moving all of these pages and minor editing. I don't know if there are more out there, but I wanted to get opinions on what people think. | ||
Revision as of 00:52, 12 September 2007
It's A Start
Just saw that you were working on this and I really like what you've got so far. --DawnBurn 14:21, 5 September 2007 (PDT)
- Thanks Dawn! I know that we have not really needed this so far with just a few editors, but clearly people needed more info, and Leigh even asked me where something was the other day. This is a work in progress, though, so please feel free to bring up issues for discussion, or edit, add as needed. It was looking so quiet around here today, I was worried we had broken the wiki! --Kay T 14:44, 5 September 2007 (PDT)
This page looks great and has been SOOO helpful, there are no words. Thanks, Kay T! ---Robini 14:35, 11 September 2007 (PDT)
Author Name Format
- Oh, but one question - (Ok, two now that I think about it)
- 1) Did you want to include instructions for Author names with spaces (like we ran into in the Cheryl St.John v. Cheryl St. John issue, and
- 2) When listing authors alphabetically, should we bother with "Firstname Last|Lastname First" syntax as they do here - Erotic Romance, or just leave the format as "Firstname Last" Format, to avoid confusion when new users populate pages? Personally, I am leaning towards the latter, having just found articles for "Racy Li" and "Li, Racy" that were identical, and most likely came from the page I linked to.--Robini 14:43, 11 September 2007 (PDT)
- Things to add:
- 1 - Author names with spaces (like we ran into in the Cheryl St.John v. Cheryl St. John issue - what did we decide on this?
- 2 - Author names when more than one author with same name - What did we decide on this?
- 3 - how to list Author names in list:
- okay, I sort of like the list entries to be Last, First (but I had recently noticed the problem with author pages being created in that format too!). The author "First Last" format is what shows up in categories, I think. Maybe we should leave this out there for discussion a little while. --Kay T 16:02, 11 September 2007 (PDT)
- My thought: Have all be of the same format "First Last". If you wish to display them as "Last, First" do so using the pipe: [[First Last | Last, First]]. And do redirects for any pages that already created under the Last, First to First Last.
Reissued books
More Style guide questions. What is the stance on books that have been reissued? There are a bunch by Kate Hill
And they have (reissue) in the title. I can tell from websearching that these were all previously published, but that those publications are no longer in print. Personally, I think having one page for the title (sans reissue) with a note that they were originally published elsewhere (include name of publication/publisher if possible) and that they are currently published by Ellora's Cave. Which would mean moving all of these pages and minor editing. I don't know if there are more out there, but I wanted to get opinions on what people think.
